Raised Beds: Why Every Garlic Grower Should Use Them 6 Comments
Using raised beds for growing vegetables has been around for thousands of years. People learned early on, that by building up the soil into mounds or beds, they could improve the growth of their crops.
Today, this tradition of growing garlic on raised beds is being continued by farmers and gardeners all over the world. It is also being "relearned" by many growers that lost the knowledge regarding the benefits of raised bed farming or gardening.
The Benefits
A number of years ago when I first started growing vegetables on a large scale, a good friend of mine suggested that I start growing all my crops on raised beds.
He is a smart guy and his explanation seemed to make sense. He said it would warm up the soil earlier in spring, help with drainage issues, would improve the soil structure and would allow me to apply less manure or compost on my fields.
So I took his advice and starting growing my garlic and other vegetables on raised beds. The difference was actually quite amazing and I noticed the following things:
(1) My crops came up faster in spring
(2) When it rained heavily I didn't worry about the plants drowning
(3) Weeding was easier because the soil was looser
(4) The plants looked extremely vigorous and healthy.
I also noticed that the biggest difference could be seen in my root crops like garlic, onions and carrots. This eventually allowed me to focus on growing mostly garlic, which would have been impossible without changing to raised beds.
Where did it go?
This was all great and I was happy that I made the change to raised bed farming, but I wondered why on earth I had never been taught this valuable method of growing. I called up my 80-year-old grandfather and asked him if he had ever seen anyone using raised beds or mounds for growing vegetables.
Surprisingly he said yes, of course. His parents and grandparents used to grow all their garden vegetables on long raised beds when he was growing up and that the vegetables all grew wonderfully.
Naturally, I asked him why the heck everyone stopped using this technique to grow things (especially because of our clay soils). He said that as soon as they starting making gas rototillers, the raised beds kind of disappeared. It was easier to plant the vegetables in long single rows with wide spacing so that you could rototill between the row. That meant that you need wide, flat garden areas where raised beds didn't work well.
Obviously using the tiller made things a lot easier in terms of weeding, but getting rid of the raised beds ended up hurting the health of the garden over the long term.
My grandfather said that all that heavy rototilling (50 years+) ended up hurting the soil, making it worse and worse over time. The more you tilled, the harder the soil got, which meant you had to till more to loosen up the soil again (a bad cycle).
This meant that the tilling became harder every year and the vegetables seemed to continuously get weaker - to the point where taking care of the garden became too much to maintain.
Today
Today most people know that excessive tillage hurts the soil and its hard to find someone that hasn't heard of using raised beds for growing garlic. Many growers have already been using them for many years and would gladly attest to their value.
There are also many books out there that are written solely on the topic of raised bed gardening and it's almost impossible to find a general gardening book that doesn't have a chapter dedicated to the technique.
Ironically, something "new" is often just something "old" that was rediscovered. I'm thankful it didn't take me long to "discover" this remarkably helpful method that grows garlic so well.
About the Author: John Côté owns and operates John Boy Farms with his family who have been farming the same land for over 140 years. As an agronomist and experienced farmer, he helps other growers learn how to grow garlic successfully. He has written many articles and is the author of The Master Guide to Growing Big Garlic.
Comments
Anonymous on August 10, 2021 23:49
It is important to rotate your garlic into different beds or growing areas every year. There should be at least 3 years between the last garlic crop (or other alliums like onions) and a new one. This is a best practice and will lower the chance of diseases or pests building up in the soil over time.
Janet Markovic on August 10, 2021 14:24
I love you blogs.
When using raised beds to plant garlic do you have to rotate them. Can you continue to plant garlic in the same bed each year?
Anonymous on October 8, 2020 18:44
There are a lot of growers in places with freeze/thaw cycles like southern Ontario and the Northern US that use raised beds without any issues. Generally speaking, the raised beds shouldn’t be a problem if you add a thick layer of mulch cover for the winter. Straw is best, however, hay or leaves can work also. The mulch is really good at preventing temperature fluctuations in the soil. It’s also important to not make beds that are too high. Personally, I don’t like beds that are more than 4 to 6 inches high. This usually minimizes the amount of freeze/thaw and reduces the chance of winter kill.
Denise on October 8, 2020 18:44
I have been planting all my vegetables in raised beds, (berms) about 18 inches high for several years now. Gardeners on a recent garden phone-in show said that their garlic did not grow well due to our wet weather. Mine were well developed and large. Although I didn’t know it, growing in raised beds was the answer to excessive rain and drainage problems which can ruin a crop.
Tracy Horsman on October 8, 2020 18:42
I’m in Nova Scotia Canada and basically have the same question as George (above). We’re Zone 5, verging on Zone 4. Our winter’s are generally mild, but with lots of freeze-thaw events. I’m worried the regular fluctuations in temperature above and below freezing will cause problems for this root crop in raised beds. Welcome your thoughts.
George McCullough on July 25, 2020 10:42
My friend has a bad back. We live in Canandaigua, NY. He wants to raise garlic in raised beds 3 feet off the ground in boxes 14 inches deep. They are 2.5 feet wide by 12 feet
long. I am concerned the garlic would freeze out. What are your thoughts and experience with such beds?